Looking for a Deal on Happiness?

When it comes to “buying” happiness, there are good and bad investments. Things that appeal to us because of “learned preferences”—for instance, luxury goods—may provide less long-lasting happiness than things we desire because of a hardwired biological preference, according to research by the University of Florida’s Yanping Tu and Chicago Booth’s Christopher K. Hsee. The authors cite interviews Hsee and a group of coresearchers conducted with residents of 31 Chinese cities about happiness derived from the ambient room temperature in their homes during winter (a hardwired, inherent preference) and that derived from the value of their jewelry (a learned preference). The results suggest happiness from learned preferences is highly context dependent.

Happiness with room temperature is absolute.

In winter, people derived more pleasure from their ambient room temperature the warmer it got. The effect held within and across cities—home temperatures are higher in Beijing (due to standard heating) than in Nanjing, and also tend to provide Beijing residents with more happiness—suggesting that home-climate happiness isn’t due to social comparison.

 
A similar scatterplot charts happiness ratings on the y-axis and average jewelry value on the x-axis. Dots for the same thirty-one cities range from five to four-point-four on the y-axis and three thousand to ten thousand R.M.B. on the x-axis, with a fairly flat, slightly downward sloping trend line. The dot for Wuhan sits at four-point-six-five on the happiness scale and four thousand three hundred on the jewelry-value scale. And the dot for Shanghai sits slightly higher at four-point-seven-four on the happiness scale and significantly greater on the jewelry value scale at nine thousand seven hundred.

Happiness with jewelry is relative.
Within cities, people with more-valuable jewelry tended to be happier than those with less-valuable jewelry. But the same wasn’t true across cities: residents of Wuhan and Shanghai derived similar amounts of happiness from their jewelry, despite a dramatic contrast in its value, suggesting that happiness that comes from jewelry value is based on social comparison.

 
A scatterplot charting happiness ratings on the y-axis and average room temperature during winter on the x-axis. Thirty-one dots representing cities range from five-point-four to four-point-four on the y-axis and follow an upward trend line along the x-axis as temperatures increase from fourteen to twenty degrees Celsius. The dot for Beijing sits at five-point-one-eight on the happiness scale and eighteen-point-six degrees. And the dot for Nanjing sits at lower at four-point-six on the happiness scale and fifteen on the temperature scale.

More from Chicago Booth Review

Related Topics

More from Chicago Booth

Related Topics

Your Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.